My Lady Jane by Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton and Jodi Meadows – Review!



414 pages – YA Historical Fiction/Romance – Standalone
3 minute review read

The Book

This alternative history follows Lady Jane Grey and her husband, Gifford Dudley (please call him G!). It’s very light-hearted, and I love that a lot of the changes they made really helped make it so fun. There is all the conflict, double-crossing and allegiances of the Protestant v. Catholic tension at the time, but instead of religious conflict, its people-who-can-turn-into-animals-and-their-supporters v. people-who-think-that-turning-into-animals-is-a-crime.

I’ll expand on the lore and alternate world a bit now, basically, some people can turn into animals at will, or sometimes involuntarily. They’ve been long prosecuted as deviations from the natural order. However, King Henry the VIII suddenly starts turning into a lion when he’s mad, so being a person who can turn into an animal is suddenly legal and encouraged – though of course they are still very distrusted in regular communities.

Yet, despite this, the book is a fun romp through what should, by most reason, be quite sad at times. The writing voices of these three women come together seamlessly – I couldn’t tell what was written by who to any extent, and the voice was amazingly fun and enjoyable to read. The humour running throughout was nothing short of brilliant, and created great juxtaposition with the few moments of despair or hopelessness that are needed in any book with coherent plot and stakes, especially in this time.

I also think this book is wonderfully self-aware in it’s deviations from history and the odd modern phrase or mannerism that crept in was perfectly acknowledged and made into a joke. The book is split in two parts ‘Part One, where we revise some history’ and ‘Part Two, where history is thrown out the window’ (or some words to that effect). And the clownish irreverence of instances like this throughout the book was charming and right up my brand of humour.

So, in short, I don’t recommend this book for a stunningly complex plot, or gut-wrenching beautiful emotiveness found in other books, but just for a book that paints a good picture of Tudor England through the eyes of three young protagonists who see the irony and humour in their dark time. Who get up to some interesting escapades and continue making us laugh from start to finish. Who, it feels to me, now get to be more than a personality-less footnote of history.

I don’t think this book is meant to be taken very seriously, and just treated for what it is – amazingly funny and fun, and a version of history I would have much preferred.

4 Stars – Might reread (if i find myself a copy) – Recommend

Recent-est Stuff

LPs and Libraries

Five Star: The Holy Trinity – loveable characters, indescribable plot (and twists!), and writing voice like a god.

Four Star: Like a five star, but maybe Just Didn’t Click like a five star would, still definitely recommend

Three Star: Maybe I didn’t like the main character but loved the plot. Or maybe the other way around. Read the review.

Two Star: Meh. Not horrific. Something made me get to the end.

One Star: I could barely finish, but I did.

DNF (Did Not Finish): I didn’t finish. Self explanatory. (Maybe it was me, maybe it was the book.)

RATINGS FOR MUSIC

Five Star: Will be played, on loop for weeks.

Four Star: Not necessarily on loop, but definitely gonna be heard a lot of.

Three Star: I’ve gotta be in the mood for it, but still a solid album/song.

Two Star: Technically or objectively good, but not my thing.

One Star: For whatever reason, I just don’t like it.